A regression model fit to data from all 23 cities finds a statistically significant linear relationship between numbers of violent crimes in American cities and their populations. For each increase of 1,000 in population, the number of violent crimes increases by 0.1093 on average. 48.6% of the variation in number of violent crimes can be explained by its relationship with population. Because these data are observational, i.e. collected without experimental intervention, it cannot be said that larger populations cause larger numbers of crimes, but only that such an association appears to exist. However, this linear relationship is mostly determined by New York City whose population and number of violent crimes are much larger than any other city, and thus accounts for a large fraction of the variation in the data. When New York is removed from the analysis there is no longer a statistically significant linear relationship and the linear relationship with population explains less than 9% of the variation in number of violent crimes.